Carmelo Anthony vs. Jimmy Butler Comparison

Head-to-head comparison between the NBA stars Jimmy Butler and Carmelo Anthony that includes championships won, honors and awards obtained, regular season and playoffs stats and other data put side by side.

Who scored more points in his career? Who averaged more points in playoffs? Who won more championships? Who led the season more times? Who won more MVP awards? These questions and many more, are answered here. It includes NBA Championships, seasons, playoffs, awards, statistical data for points, rebounds, assists, steals, blocks and percentages.

Head-To-Head Career Comparison

NBA Timeline:
1946-47
2023-24
Carmelo Anthony:
2003-04 to 2021-22
Jimmy Butler:
2011-12 to 2023-24

NBA Championships and Seasons

Carmelo Anthony0
Jimmy Butler0
Carmelo Anthony19
Jimmy Butler13
Carmelo Anthony13
Jimmy Butler11
Carmelo Anthony10
Jimmy Butler6

Honors and Awards

All-NBA Teams
(Total Selections)
Carmelo Anthony6
Jimmy Butler5
All-Defensive Teams
(Total Selections)
Carmelo Anthony0
Jimmy Butler5
Carmelo Anthony1
Jimmy Butler0
Carmelo Anthony0
Jimmy Butler1

NBA Regular Season Stats

Stats Per Game

Carmelo Anthony 22.5
Jimmy Butler 18.3

Carmelo Anthony 6.2
Jimmy Butler 5.4

Carmelo Anthony 2.7
Jimmy Butler 4.2

Carmelo Anthony 1.0
Jimmy Butler 1.6

Carmelo Anthony 0.5
Jimmy Butler 0.5

Totals Stats

Carmelo Anthony 28,289
Jimmy Butler 14,695

Carmelo Anthony 7,808
Jimmy Butler 4,290

Carmelo Anthony 3,422
Jimmy Butler 3,401

Carmelo Anthony 1,223
Jimmy Butler 1,309

Carmelo Anthony 644
Jimmy Butler 361

Carmelo Anthony 1,260
Jimmy Butler 801

Percentages

Field Goal Percentage
Carmelo Anthony .447
Jimmy Butler .470

3-Point Percentage
Carmelo Anthony .355
Jimmy Butler .328

Free Throw Percentage
Carmelo Anthony .814
Jimmy Butler .843

Best Season (no game minimum)

Carmelo Anthony 28.9
(2007)
Jimmy Butler 23.9
(2017)

Carmelo Anthony 8.1
(2014)
Jimmy Butler 6.9
(2021)

Carmelo Anthony 4.2
(2016)
Jimmy Butler 7.1
(2021)

Carmelo Anthony 1.3
(2010)
Jimmy Butler 2.1
(2021)

Carmelo Anthony 0.8
(2022)
Jimmy Butler 0.6
(2016)

NBA Playoffs Stats

Stats Per Game

Carmelo Anthony 23.1
Jimmy Butler 21.3

Carmelo Anthony 6.7
Jimmy Butler 6.2

Carmelo Anthony 2.5
Jimmy Butler 4.6

Carmelo Anthony 1.2
Jimmy Butler 1.7

Carmelo Anthony 0.3
Jimmy Butler 0.6

Totals Stats

Carmelo Anthony 1,914
Jimmy Butler 2,534

Carmelo Anthony 557
Jimmy Butler 734

Carmelo Anthony 204
Jimmy Butler 551

Carmelo Anthony 100
Jimmy Butler 202

Carmelo Anthony 29
Jimmy Butler 68

Carmelo Anthony 83
Jimmy Butler 119

Percentages

Field Goal Percentage
Carmelo Anthony .414
Jimmy Butler .460

3-Point Percentage
Carmelo Anthony .324
Jimmy Butler .347

Free Throw Percentage
Carmelo Anthony .826
Jimmy Butler .830

Best Playoffs (no game minimum)

Carmelo Anthony 30.7
(2010)
Jimmy Butler 27.4
(2022)

Carmelo Anthony 10.3
(2011)
Jimmy Butler 7.5
(2021)

Carmelo Anthony 4.8
(2011)
Jimmy Butler 7.0
(2021)

Carmelo Anthony 2.0
(2010)
Jimmy Butler 2.4
(2015)

Carmelo Anthony 0.8
(2011)
Jimmy Butler 0.8
(2017)